PW Gap Map

Built from the 60 readable Cat 7 reports in “PW Data” (7-14 and 7-57 were too large to preview, 7-41 had no file). Each project is coded by who it serves and how. Dashed cells are white space. Click any cell, row or tag to see the projects.

1. Positioning map: beneficiary × approach

Click a cell to list its projects.

2. Saturation by segment

Share of the 60 projects serving each segment. A project counts once, under its main beneficiary.

3. Segments with no project at all in this data

Absence only. Validate demand with a needs survey and a partner before committing.

Physical disabilities / wheelchair usersCaregivers of seniors or special-needs familyPatients in hospice or hospitalAt-risk or delinquent youth (pre-offending)Low-income working adults (financial literacy)Children in foster care or single-parent households (as the main focus)Domestic workersYouth with chronic illnessNeighbourhood food insecurityMainstream-school students with special needs

4. Limitations of current projects

Measurement quality is my coding of each report. The patterns below are quoted from the reports’ own difficulties.

Oversaturated
  • Senior befriending and phone-skills: 19 projects. Voice’s partner warned of an oversaturation of soft-skills programmes eating study time.
  • Most senior projects use near-identical games, crafts and outings.
Weak proof of impact
  • Most report satisfaction %, not change over time.
  • Voice and Welcove say outright they cannot prove lasting effect.
  • Seniors often couldn’t complete forms (Silver Lining).
Fragile continuity
  • Luminary, Articulate and Apricus give no formal handover.
  • Refresh had no successor found by September.
  • Many hand over every year to Sec 3 students, so know-how resets.
Access and partner limits
  • PDPA and consent rules block photos and publicity (Unbound, Christalite).
  • Partners declined or couldn’t host: Ferox (ACRES/SPCA), Pawsitive, PEACE-Connect.
  • Uplift couldn’t apply for the Young Changemakers Grant.
Scope and time
  • PSLE periods cost Chillax 4 sessions.
  • Greenlite changed its aim mid-year; Catharsis dropped three planned modules.
  • Rejuvenate stayed small: few sessions, slow partner replies.
Unusually good practice
  • Voice: parallel core teams across schools and a planned measurement tool.
  • Little But Loud: 73.3% to 26.7% of seniors with no youth friends.
  • Hear Me Out: confidence 3.1 to 3.9 pre/post.